| L. Dilley | 210no | 1967/68 | First Grade; Premier League | S/F | Kincumber-Avoca |
| L. Roberts | 182no | 1967/68 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | Woy Woy |
| J. Davis | 178 | 1964/65 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Gosford |
| V. Clifton | 171 | 1954/55 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Kincumber |
| J. Davis | 169no | 1965/66 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | The Entrance |
| L. Dilley | 168 | 1967/68 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Gosford |
| V. Clifton | 165 | 1951/52 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Mangrove Mountain |
| James Boettiger | 161 | 2007/08 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Woy Woy |
| Ryan Fenning | 159 (240) | 2024/25 | First Grade; Premier League | 5 | Wyong |
| Nadeem Mohammed | 158 | 2002/03 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Narara-Wyoming |
| L. Dilley | 152no | 1961/62 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | The Entrance |
| V. Clifton | 151 | 1951/52 | First Grade; Premier League | 14 | Mangrove Mountain |
| L. Dilley | 150 | 1957/58 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Avoca |
| L. Dilley | 146 | 1957/58 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | Gosford |
| D. Collins | 143 | 1968/69 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Woy Woy |
| D. Fagan | 140 | 1947/48 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | The Entrance |
| Peter Coombes | 140 | 1980/81 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Toukley |
| Andrew Littlefield | 139 | 2007/08 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Doyalson-Wyee |
| L. Dilley | 136 | 1958/59 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | West Gosford |
| L. Roberts | 136no | 1970/71 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Umina |
| D. Collins | 134 | 1967/68 | First Grade; Premier League | 10 | The Entrance |
| V. Clifton | 133 | 1949/50 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Matcham-Holgate |
| L. Dilley | 132no | 1968/69 | First Grade; Premier League | 10 | Kincumber-Avoca |
| David Mitchell | 131 | 2014/15 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Terrigal-Matcham |
| Jeff Hemming | 128 | 2006/07 | First Grade; Premier League | G/F | Mountains-Kariong |
| D. Collins | 127no | 1962/63 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Ryan Fenning | 125 | 2016/17 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Wyong |
| Trent Riley | 124 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Toukley |
| Trent Riley | 123 | 2010/11 | First Grade; Premier League | 10 | Toukley |
| Warren Mulligan | 121no | 1985/86 | First Grade; Premier League | 10 | The Entrance |
| Trent Riley | 121 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Gosford |
| V. Clifton | 119 | 1947/48 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | The Entrance |
| L. Roberts | 119no | 1969/70 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | The Entrance |
| Darren Bates | 119 | 1999/00 | First Grade; Premier League | 11 | Woy Woy |
| V. Clifton | 117 | 1954/55 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Narara |
| L. Dilley | 117 | 1955/56 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Trent Riley | 117 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | Narara-Wyoming |
| J. Davis | 116 | 1948/49 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Gosford |
| V. Clifton | 116 | 1952/53 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | Matcham-Holgate |
| L. Dilley | 116no | 1967/68 | First Grade; Premier League | 14 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Ashley Hardy | 116 | 1992/93 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Mountains-Kariong |
| Darren Bates | 116 | 2002/03 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Umina |
| Ben Cohen | 116 | 2019/20 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Kincumber-Avoca |
| Jeff Hemming | 115 | 2007/08 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Wyong |
| Peter Coombes | 114 | 1981/82 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Doyalson-Wyee |
| Scott Thompson | 114 | 2008/09 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Woy Woy |
| Brett Roberts | 113no | 1993/94 | First Grade; Premier League | 12 | Woy Woy |
| Jeff Hemming | 113no | 2007/08 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Toukley |
| Trent Riley | 113 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | Wyong |
| L. Dilley | 112 | 1956/57 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | The Entrance |
| L. Dilley | 112 | 1965/66 | First Grade; Premier League | 12 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Sebastian Reid | 112 | 2002/03 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Wyong |
| V. Clifton | 111 | 1948/49 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Gosford |
| J. Taylor | 111 | 1951/52 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Narara |
| J. Dawson | 110 | 1964/65 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Ryan Fenning | 110no | 2019/20 | First Grade; Premier League | 13 | The Entrance |
| J. Davis | 109no | 1959/60 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Woy Woy |
| J. Davidson | 109 | 1961/62 | First Grade; Premier League | 12 | Gosford |
| J. Davis | 107 | 1960/61 | First Grade; Premier League | 14 | The Entrance |
| J. Davidson | 107 | 1962/63 | First Grade; Premier League | 6 | The Entrance |
| Scott Thompson | 107no | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Gosford |
| Chris Sheppeard | 107no | 2012/13 | First Grade; Premier League | 5 | Doyalson-Wyee |
| L. Dilley | 106 | 1956/57 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | East Gosford |
| Trent Riley | 106 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Woy Woy |
| Ryan Fenning | 106 | 2012/13 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Mountains-Kariong |
| A. Taylor | 105 | 1953/54 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Matcham-Holgate |
| V. Clifton | 105 | 1955/56 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Gosford |
| P. Freemantle | 105 | 1979/80 | First Grade; Premier League | S/F | Narara-Wyoming |
| Ian Howell | 105 | 1991/92 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Mountains-Kariong |
| Ryan Fenning | 105* (100) | 2024/25 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | The Entrance |
| C. Reddy | 104no | 1957/58 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | East Gosford |
| Cameron Wehrle | 104 (200) | 2025/26 | First Grade; Premier League | 16 | Southern Spirit |
| L. Dilley | 103no | 1959/60 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Peats Ridge |
| Ben Cohen | 103 | 2020/21 | First Grade; Premier League | 16 | Warnervale |
| Ben Cohen | 103 | 2020/21 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | The Entrance |
| Ryan Fenning | 103 (175) | 2024/25 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Southern Spirit |
| M. Stephenson | 102no | 1974/75 | First Grade; Premier League | 4 | Umina |
| Les Roberts | 102no | 1981/82 | First Grade; Premier League | 5 | The Entrance |
| Andrew Littlefield | 101no | 2007/08 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Narara-Wyoming |
| Mitchell McBeath | 101 | 2009/10 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Doyalson-Wyee |
| Ryan Fenning | 101no | 2012/13 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Toukley |
| Blair Lindsay | 101 | 2019/20 | First Grade; Premier League | 11 | Southern Spirit |
| D. Fagan | 100no | 1947/48 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Kincumber |
| D. Fagan | 100 | 1948/49 | First Grade; Premier League | 8 | Gosford |
| J. Davis | 100 | 1954/55 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Kincumber |
| L. Dilley | 100no | 1961/62 | First Grade; Premier League | 1 | Kincumber-Avoca |
| Willmott. R | 100no | 1999/00 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Matcham-Holgate |
| Trent Riley | 100 | 2002/03 | First Grade; Premier League | 9 | Wyong |
| Jeff Hemming | 100no | 2006/07 | First Grade; Premier League | 3 | Gosford |
| Brady J Pennington | 100 (62) | 2022/23 | First Grade; Premier League | 7 | Southern Spirit |
| Jamie Brown | 100 (42) | 2025/26 | First Grade; Premier League | 2 | Northern Power |